Frequently Asked Questions

Head to our Order page to build your box and check out. You'll select your cookies, choose a porch pickup or delivery date, and send payment via Venmo. We'll take it from there.

Orders close Wednesday at midnight for that weekend's Friday and Saturday porch pickup and Sunday delivery. After Wednesday, the next available dates are the following weekend. This lets us bake every batch fresh and to order — never sitting on a shelf waiting for you.

Unfortunately no. Because everything is made to order and baked in weekly batches, orders close Wednesday at midnight for that weekend. Plan ahead and we promise it's worth the wait.

Absolutely — that's kind of the whole point. Our Build Your Box section lets you mix and match any combination of flavors. Order one of everything, double up on your favorite, or keep it classic. It's entirely up to you.

Yes — our minimum order is 3 cookies. You can mix and match any flavors, or grab The Trio: any 3 flavors for $10.

We're based in Byron Center, Michigan. Once payment is received, we'll text you a confirmation with our porch pickup address. Your order will be waiting in our porch pickup cabinet, labeled with your name, at the start of your pickup window — no need to knock, just come grab it. Porch pickup orders must be paid in advance.

Porch pickup is available Fridays 4–7pm and Saturdays 10am–1pm. Come any time during your window. Orders not picked up by the end of the window are brought inside — just message us to arrange a time to get them.

Yes! We offer free Sunday delivery, 12–2pm, within Byron Center (49315). We'll text you when we're on the way. Someone must be home to receive the order — cookies will not be left unattended.

Our pricing is simple — $4 per cookie, with savings on packs. Individual cookies are available à la carte, or choose The Trio (any 3 flavors for $10) or The Dozen Box (any 12 flavors for $39).

The Trio is any 3 cookies for $10, packed in a bag — you pick the flavors. Just list your three in the Flavor Picks box when you order. It's the perfect way to try us for the first time or share with a friend.

We use real, honest ingredients — the kind you'd already find in your own pantry. Cold butter, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla, and quality chocolate. No artificial preservatives, no mystery additives. Just good ingredients handled with care.

All of our cookies contain wheat, eggs, and dairy. Our Salted Caramel cookie also contains tree nuts (almonds) via Heath toffee bits. All cookies are baked in the same kitchen, so cross-contact is possible. If you have a severe allergy, please reach out before ordering at hello@thecookieedit.com.

Yes — every order is baked to order. We never pre-bake and stockpile. Your cookies are made for you, for your pickup date, and that's it. That's how we keep quality exactly where it needs to be.

Our cookies are best enjoyed within 3 days of pickup, stored at room temperature in their packaging. If you need to keep them longer, they freeze beautifully — just seal in an airtight bag and thaw at room temperature when you're ready.

Yes! Whether it's a birthday, corporate event, wedding, or any occasion worth celebrating — we'd love to be part of it. Reach out to us at orders@thecookieedit.com for large order inquiries and availability.

We love working with creators who share our passion for quality food and beautiful content. Send us a message at hello@thecookieedit.com with your handle and a little about what you have in mind. We'll get back to you soon.